|
Kilmacolm – Port Glasgow Road: former Quarry
Background
7.439
This irregularly shaped site extends to 0.6ha and is located immediately beyond the built-up area at the entrance to Kilmacolm on the north east side of Port Glasgow Road. Much of it was previously a stone quarry, but the north west corner contains some trees. Until recently the quarry floor also contained many young trees and shrubs. The south eastern part of the site is within the settlement boundary; it is open ground in front of a detached house 'Marchfield' which, together with its neighbour 'Torbank', is set well back from Port Glasgow Road. On the other side of the road, grazing land falls away to the former railway line (now a cycle track). To the north west and north, a minor road leads up to the village cemetery. To the north east is further grazing land.
7.440
2 outline applications for the erection of 3 dwellinghouses and garages have been refused by the council in recent times. The first was taken to appeal, which was dismissed in May 2002 (P/PPA/280/43). In reaching his decision, the Reporter made the following relevant comments:
"23. As the site of a former quarry, the appeal site meets the definition of a brownfield
site which is set out in NPPG 3, i.e. it is a site which has previously been developed or used for some purpose which has ceased. However, quarrying normally takes place outwith settlement boundaries, and I do not consider therefore that the redevelopment of former quarries for housing would always be an appropriate use.
24.
Here, the built-up area of Kilmacolm has now extended right up to the edge of the quarry site. This location, together with its position contained within 2 public roads, would support its development as an extension to the built-up area; and its accessibility to the village centre and bus routes, and its sheltered south-facing position offer advantages in terms of sustainability. On the other hand, the site also serves to provide a relatively strong landscaped edge to the settlement. This is due to the fairly dense vegetative cover which has re-colonised the quarry floor, together with the site's position immediately before a bend in the A761. This enables the village to be hidden from the view of those approaching Kilmacolm on this road.
25.
In these circumstances, I consider that the appeal site in its present condition does serve a useful function, and I find that the proposed development would have an adverse impact on the landscape setting of Kilmacolm. In the event of a need being identified for further land for housing development to be released in Kilmacolm, I agree that the comparative merits of this site would have to be assessed along with those of other sites. However, that would be a matter to be resolved through the local plan process, rather than through an individual planning application or appeal.
26. Drawing these findings together, therefore,
my final conclusions are that the suitability of the site as an extension to the village is not so great as to justify granting outline planning permission for this proposed housing development in the green belt, which would be contrary to the relevant provisions of the development plan, and would not be supported by the relevant provisions of the emerging local plan."
The second application was also refused by the council in January 2004.
Read more about the Former Quarry here... |
|